Menu
Cy Young

Image above: Cy Young. Right: Fenway Park in 1914. Photos courtesy Library of Congress.

Fenway Park

Hall of Fame Position Ranks

1871-2017 (Regular Season)



PITCHERS


Rank
First Name Last Name TOTAL
PEVA

Yrs.
PEVA-T
Per Yr.

HR

RBI

Ave.

W

SV

ERA
1 Greg Maddux 594.209 23 25.835 5 84 0.171 355 0 3.16
2 Cy Young 505.634 22 22.983 18 290 0.210 511 17 2.63
3 Walter Johnson 488.778 21 23.275 24 255 0.235 417 34 2.17
4 Pete Alexander 387.680 20 19.384 11 163 0.209 373 32 2.56
5 Randy Johnson 408.708 22 18.578 1 40 0.125 303 2 3.29
6 Warren Spahn 372.497 21 17.738 35 189 0.194 363 29 3.09
7 Lefty Grove 342.629 17 20.155 15 121 0.148 300 55 3.06
8 Tom Seaver 336.144 20 16.807 12 86 0.154 311 1 2.86
9 Pedro Martinez 328.493 18 18.250 0 18 0.099 219 3 2.93
10 Steve Carlton 328.713 24 13.696 13 140 0.201 329 2 3.22
11 Tom Glavine 325.047 22 14.775 1 90 0.186 305 0 3.54
12 Kid Nichols 316.988 15 21.133 16 278 0.226 361 17 2.95
13 Robin Roberts 309.046 19 16.266 5 103 0.167 286 25 3.41
14 Carl Hubbell 302.043 16 18.878 4 101 0.191 253 33 2.98
15 John Smoltz 301.456 21 14.355 5 61 0.159 215 154 3.33
16 Christy Mathewson 293.500 17 17.265 7 165 0.215 373 28 2.13
17 Gaylord Perry 286.329 22 13.015 6 47 0.131 314 11 3.11
16 Bert Blylevin 271.050 22 12.320 0 25 0.131 287 0 3.31
19 Nolan Ryan 270.539 27 10.020 2 36 0.110 324 3 3.19
20 Phil Niekro 269.835 24 11.243 7 109 0.169 318 29 3.35
21 Don Sutton 266.168 23 11.573 0 64 0.144 324 5 3.26
22 Fergie Jenkins 250.825 19 13.201 13 85 0.165 284 7 3.34
23 Bob Feller 246.598 18 13.700 8 99 0.151 266 21 3.25
24 Jim Palmer 240.182 19 12.641 3 41 0.174 268 4 2.86
25 Jim Bunning 232.753 17 13.691 7 75 0.167 224 16 3.27
26 Juan Marichal 231.781 16 14.486 4 75 0.165 243 2 2.89
27 Don Drysdale 231.166 14 16.512 29 113 0.186 209 6 2.95
28 Bob Gibson 227.176 17 13.363 24 144 0.206 251 6 2.91
29 Early Wynn 223.795 23 9.730 17 173 0.214 300 15 3.54
30 Hal Newhouser 219.148 17 12.891 2 81 0.201 207 26 3.06
31 Dennis Eckersley 217.107 24 9.046 3 12 0.133 197 390 3.50
32 Ed Walsh 214.819 14 15.344 3 68 0.193 195 34 1.82
33 Dazzy Vance 212.748 16 13.297 7 75 0.150 197 11 3.24
34 Amos Rusie 210.560 10 21.056 8 176 0.247 245 5 3.07
35 Sandy Koufax 206.787 12 17.232 2 28 0.097 165 9 2.76
36 Eppa Rixey 202.106 21 9.624 3 111 0.191 266 14 3.15
37 Whitey Ford 201.182 16 12.574 3 69 0.173 236 10 2.75
38 John Clarkson 197.394 12 16.449 24 232 0.219 328 5 2.81
39 Jack Morris 194.913 18 10.829 0 0 0.000 254 0 3.90
40 Burleigh Grimes 187.970 19 9.893 2 168 0.248 270 18 3.53
41 Ted Lyons 180.468 21 8.594 5 149 0.233 260 23 3.67
42 Tim Keefe 178.455 14 12.747 12 134 0.187 342 2 2.62
43 Red Faber 177.411 20 8.871 3 70 0.134 254 28 3.15
44 Stan Coveleski 176.253 14 12.589 1 81 0.159 215 21 2.89
45 Joe McGinnity 176.188 10 17.619 0 90 0.194 246 24 2.66
46 Eddie Plank 174.524 17 10.266 3 122 0.206 326 23 2.35
47 Catfish Hunter 172.508 15 11.501 6 51 0.226 224 1 3.26
48 Bob Lemon 171.875 15 11.458 37 147 0.232 207 22 3.23
49 Mordecai Brown 168.239 14 12.017 2 74 0.206 239 49 2.06
50 Hoyt Wilhelm 167.483 21 7.975 1 21 0.088 143 227 2.52
51 Trevor Hoffman 166.371 18 9.243 0 5 0.118 61 601 2.87
52 Red Ruffing 166.258 22 7.557 36 273 0.269 273 16 3.80
53 Dizzy Dean 163.005 12 13.584 8 76 0.225 150 30 3.02
54 Vic Willis 159.269 13 12.251 1 84 0.166 249 11 2.63
55 Pud Galvin 154.695 15 10.313 5 220 0.201 364 2 2.86
56 Charley Radbourn 153.761 12 12.813 9 259 0.235 309 2 2.67
57 Waite Hoyt 150.713 21 7.177 0 100 0.198 237 52 3.59
58 Gossage Rich 138.013 22 6.273 0 2 0.106 124 310 3.01
59 Lefty Gomez 135.569 14 9.683 0 58 0.147 189 9 3.34
60 Rollie Fingers 130.458 17 7.674 2 9 0.172 114 341 2.90
61 Rube Waddell 129.158 13 9.935 4 83 0.161 193 5 2.16
62 Herb Pennock 124.406 22 5.655 4 103 0.191 240 32 3.60
63 Addie Joss 121.462 9 13.496 1 51 0.144 160 5 1.89
64 Jack Chesbro 120.772 11 10.979 5 82 0.197 198 5 2.68
65 Jesse Haines 116.440 19 6.128 3 79 0.186 210 10 3.64
66 Mickey Welch 115.650 13 8.896 12 202 0.224 307 4 2.71
67 Chief Bender 109.459 16 6.841 6 116 0.212 212 34 2.46
68 Bruce Sutter 108.819 12 9.068 0 6 0.088 68 300 2.83
69 Rube Marquard 104.505 18 5.806 1 64 0.179 201 19 3.08
NL Ray Brown Upcoming 15 Upcoming 22 98 0.261 92 NA 4.14
NL Leon Day Upcoming 10 Upcoming 3 61 0.286 33 NA 4.51
NL Martin Dihigo Upcoming 12 Upcoming 57 190 0.304 22 NA 4.18
NL Bill Foster Upcoming 15 Upcoming 2 20 0.203 128 NA 3.27
NL Jose Mendez Upcoming 19 Upcoming 8 74 0.210 95 NA 3.32
MLB
NL
Satchel Paige 21.155
Upcoming
6
17
3.526
Upcoming
0
1
4
17
0.097
0.215
28
100
32
NA
3.29
3.22
NL Bullet Rogan Upcoming 17 Upcoming 45 199 .338 119 NA 3.68
NL Hilton Smith Upcoming 13 Upcoming 2 34 0.323 57 NA 3.44
NL Joe Williams Upcoming 18 Upcoming 9 70 0.291 84 NA 3.79
NL Andy Cooper Upcoming NA Upcoming NA NA NA NA NA NA


Sponsor this page for $75 per year or all five Hall of Fame Position Rank pages for $250. Your banner or text ad can fill the space above. Click here to Sponsor the page and see how to reserve your ad.

  • What is PEVA?

    PEVA is the acronym for Stat Geek Baseball's New Player Rating value. This grade is given to each player and pitcher each season, rating their performance on a peer to peer review. Six components for pitchers and batters are melded together into the PEVA Rating, which ranges each year from 0.200 to 64.000. For more information on PEVA and the other new Stat Geek Baseball Stats, see our Definitions page. PEVA ratings are available for every pitcher and hitter in baseball history.

    PEVA Scale

    64.000 - Maximum
    32.000 - Cy Young/MVP Candidate
    20.000 - All League
    15.000 - All-Star Level
    10.000 - Very Good
    3.500 - Average
    0.200 - Minimum


Notes: PEVA-T equals Total PEVA for Career, including both batting and pitching PEVA. Some players below 50 PEVA have not been added.

Note: Negro League stats are many times incomplete; Saves not available, ERA = Total Runs per 9IP, not ER.

Photo/Image Credits: Grover Cleveland Alexander, Christy Mathewson, Cy Young, and Fenway Park. Library of Congress.

Baseball Evaluation, Stat Geek Baseball, and all materials on this site are the 2015 Copyright and intellectual property of JDP ECON and their licensors. All worldwide rights reserved. The Baseball Evaluation system was developed independently of Major League Baseball and the Major League Baseball Players Association and is not endorsed by or associated in any way with either organization.

Note: All Baseball Evaluation Stats and Stat Geek Baseball Stats were developed by JDP Econ & are the proprietary property of JDP ECON. All rights reserved. If Baseball Evaluation stats are used in articles, etc., please credit statgeekbaseball.com or baseballevaluation.com.

For more on the Best Teams Ever, including the Top 50 batting, pitching, and total teams, plus more, check out Stat Geek Baseball, the Best Ever Book below.

  • Cheap baseball tickets


More Baseball