Player Ratings
BATTING 1-20
| Rank | Year | LastName | First | Team | Lg | HR | RBI | OBP | SLG | FV | PEVA |
| 1 | 1891 | Brouthers | Dan | BS2 | AA | 5 | 109 | 0.471 | 0.512 | 1.01 | 34.762 |
| 2 | 1891 | Brown | Tom | BS2 | AA | 5 | 72 | 0.397 | 0.469 | 1.40 | 27.645 |
| 3 | 1891 | Duffy | Hugh | BS2 | AA | 9 | 110 | 0.408 | 0.453 | 1.42 | 23.866 |
| 4 | 1891 | Hamilton | Billy | PHI | NL | 2 | 60 | 0.453 | 0.421 | 1.45 | 23.004 |
| 5 | 1891 | Tiernan | Mike | NY1 | NL | 16 | 73 | 0.388 | 0.494 | 1.30 | 21.436 |
| 6 | 1891 | Milligan | Jocko | PH4 | AA | 11 | 106 | 0.397 | 0.505 | 1.73 | 21.264 |
| 7 | 1891 | Van Haltren | George | BL3 | AA | 9 | 83 | 0.398 | 0.443 | 1.25 | 21.128 |
| 8 | 1891 | Connor | Roger | NY1 | NL | 7 | 94 | 0.399 | 0.449 | 1.40 | 20.580 |
| 9 | 1891 | Farrell | Duke | BS2 | AA | 12 | 110 | 0.384 | 0.474 | 1.53 | 20.311 |
| 10 | 1891 | Stovey | Harry | BSN | NL | 16 | 95 | 0.373 | 0.498 | 1.44 | 18.494 |
| 11 | 1891 | Long | Herman | BSN | NL | 9 | 76 | 0.377 | 0.407 | 1.75 | 16.759 |
| 12 | 1891 | Duffee | Charlie | CL6 | AA | 10 | 90 | 0.353 | 0.420 | 1.55 | 16.545 |
| 13 | 1891 | Hoy | Dummy | SL4 | AA | 5 | 66 | 0.424 | 0.360 | 1.49 | 16.384 |
| 14 | 1891 | Anson | Cap | CHN | NL | 8 | 120 | 0.378 | 0.409 | 1.39 | 15.808 |
| 15 | 1891 | Lyons | Denny | SL4 | AA | 11 | 84 | 0.445 | 0.455 | 1.27 | 15.239 |
| 16 | 1891 | Wood | George | PH4 | AA | 3 | 61 | 0.399 | 0.413 | 1.48 | 15.229 |
| 17 | 1891 | Thompson | Sam | PHI | NL | 7 | 90 | 0.363 | 0.410 | 1.57 | 15.021 |
| 18 | 1891 | Latham | Arlie | CIN | NL | 7 | 53 | 0.372 | 0.386 | 1.70 | 14.897 |
| 19 | 1891 | Werden | Perry | BL3 | AA | 6 | 104 | 0.363 | 0.424 | 1.28 | 14.884 |
| 20 | 1891 | Davis | George | CL4 | NL | 3 | 89 | 0.354 | 0.409 | 1.49 | 14.708 |
- Individual PEVA Ratings
- PEVA Details
- Baseball Tickets
All Batters 1891 - PEVA Values (Alphabetical)
| Year Last First Team PEVA | |
| 1891
Alberts Gus
ML3 0.200 1891 Allen Bob PHI 4.369 1891 Alvord Billy MULT 2.395 1891 Andrews Ed CN3 2.101 1891 Anson Cap CHN 15.808 1891 Bakely Jersey MULT 0.200 1891 Baldwin Mark PIT 0.200 1891 Barr Bob NY1 0.200 1891 Bassett Charley NY1 7.623 1891 Bastian Charlie MULT 0.200 1891 Beard Ollie LS2 1.369 1891 Beatin Ed CL4 0.200 1891 Beckley Jake PIT 11.303 1891 Beecher Ed MULT 1.966 1891 Bell Charlie MULT 0.200 1891 Bennett Charlie BSN 2.482 1891 Berger Tun PIT 0.464 1891 Bierbauer Lou PIT 3.681 1891 Boone George LS2 0.200 1891 Bowman Bill CHN 0.200 1891 Bowman Sumner PH4 0.200 1891 Boyle Jack SL4 8.149 1891 Breitenstein Ted SL4 0.200 1891 Briggs Grant LS2 0.200 1891 Brodie Steve BSN 9.040 1891 Brouthers Dan BS2 34.762 1891 Browning Pete MULT 9.373 1891 Brown Tom BS2 27.645 1891 Brown Willard PHI 3.946 1891 Brynan Tod BSN 0.200 1891 Buckley Dick NY1 1.931 1891 Buffinton Charlie BS2 0.218 1891 Burdock Jack BRO 0.200 1891 Burke Eddie ML3 0.549 1891 Burkett Jesse CL4 0.874 1891 Burke Joe CN3 0.200 1891 Burns Jim WS9 0.897 1891 Burns Oyster BRO 10.125 1891 Burns Tom CHN 0.547 1891 Burrell Buster NY1 0.200 1891 Burrell Harry SL4 0.200 1891 Cahill Tom LS2 5.483 1891 Calihan Will PH4 0.200 1891 Canavan Jim MULT 9.146 1891 Carney John MULT 5.535 1891 Carroll Cliff CHN 8.902 1891 Carroll Fred PIT 3.103 1891 Carsey Kid WS9 0.209 1891 Caruthers Bob BRO 1.244 1891 Cassian Ed MULT 0.200 1891 Chamberlain Elton PH4 0.305 1891 Childs Cupid CL4 14.432 1891 Clarke Artie NY1 0.257 1891 Clark Bob CIN 0.200 1891 Clarke Dad CL6 0.200 1891 Clarkson Dad NY1 0.200 1891 Clark Ed CL6 0.200 1891 Clarkson John BSN 0.324 1891 Clements Jack PHI 10.836 1891 Cleveland Elmer CL6 0.246 1891 Cline Monk LS2 1.139 1891 Clingman Billy CN3 0.200 1891 Clymer Bill PH4 0.200 1891 Collins Bill CL4 0.200 1891 Collins Hub BRO 4.459 1891 Comiskey Charlie SL4 7.943 1891 Connor Roger NY1 20.580 1891 Cook Paul MULT 0.331 1891 Cooney Jimmy CHN 5.880 1891 Corcoran Tommy PH4 9.922 1891 Corkhill Pop MULT 5.282 1891 Cotter Tom BS2 0.200 1891 Coughlin Roscoe NY1 0.200 1891 Crane Ed MULT 0.200 1891 Crooks Jack CL6 12.304 1891 Cross Lave PH4 8.389 1891 Cunningham Bert BL3 0.200 1891 Curtis Ervin MULT 1.235 1891 Dahlen Bill CHN 12.503 1891 Daily Con BRO 2.416 1891 Daily Ed MULT 0.348 1891 Daley Bill BS2 0.200 1891 Dalrymple Abner ML3 0.887 1891 Daly Joe CL4 0.200 1891 Daly Tom BRO 1.428 1891 Darling Dell SL4 0.200 1891 Darragh Jack LS2 0.200 1891 Davies George ML3 0.200 1891 Davis George CL4 14.708 1891 Davis Jumbo WS9 1.082 1891 Delahanty Ed PHI 8.410 1891 Denny Jerry MULT 0.458 1891 Dolan John CL6 0.200 1891 Donahue Jim CL6 2.093 1891 Donahue Tim BS2 0.200 1891 Donnelly Jim CL6 0.349 1891 Donohue Joe PHI 0.200 1891 Donovan Patsy MULT 7.756 1891 Doran John LS2 0.200 1891 Dowd Tommy MULT 3.573 1891 Dowse Tom CL6 0.490 1891 Doyle Jack CL4 2.026 1891 Duffee Charlie CL6 16.545 1891 Duffy Hugh BS2 23.866 1891 Duke Martin WS9 0.200 1891 Dunlap Fred WS9 0.200 1891 Dunning Andy NY1 0.200 1891 Duryea Jesse MULT 0.200 1891 Dwyer Frank MULT 0.361 1891 Eagan Bill SL4 1.637 1891 Earl Howard ML3 0.267 1891 Easton Jack MULT 0.200 1891 Ehret Red LS2 0.214 1891 Eiteljorge Ed WS9 0.200 1891 Ely Bones BRO 0.200 1891 Esper Duke PHI 0.200 1891 Esterbrook Dude BRO 0.200 1891 Ewing Buck NY1 0.903 1891 Ewing John NY1 0.200 1891 Farrell Duke BS2 20.311 1891 Fields Jocko MULT 0.604 1891 Fitzgerald John BS2 0.200 1891 Fitzgerald Warren LS2 0.200 1891 Flynn Mike BS2 0.200 1891 Foreman Frank MULT 1.070 1891 Foster Elmer CHN 0.200 1891 Foutz Dave BRO 6.629 1891 Fox Paddy LS2 0.200 1891 Freeman Buck WS9 0.200 1891 Friel Pat PH4 0.200 1891 Fuller Harry SL4 0.200 1891 Fuller Shorty SL4 6.542 1891 Galvin Pud PIT 0.200 1891 Ganzel Charlie BSN 1.972 1891 Gastright Hank CL6 0.236 1891 Gerhardt Joe LS2 0.200 1891 Getzein Charlie MULT 0.200 1891 Gilbert Pete BL3 8.465 1891 Glasscock Jack NY1 3.325 1891 Gleason Kid PHI 0.560 1891 Gore George NY1 11.337 1891 Gormley Joe PHI 0.200 1891 Graulich Lew PHI 0.200 1891 Gray Bill PHI 0.222 1891 Griffith Clark MULT 0.200 1891 Griffin Mike BRO 13.033 1891 Griffin Sandy WS9 1.095 1891 Grim John ML3 0.267 1891 Gruber Henry CL4 0.200 1891 Gumbert Ad CHN 1.265 1891 Haddock George BS2 0.726 1891 Halligan Jocko CIN 2.837 1891 Hallman Bill PH4 10.783 1891 Hamilton Billy PHI 23.004 1891 Hanlon Ned PIT 6.889 1891 Hardie Lou BL3 0.350 1891 Harrington Jerry CIN 2.419 1891 Hart Tom WS9 0.200 1891 Hatfield Gil WS9 6.912 1891 Healy John BL3 0.200 1891 Hemming George BRO 0.200 1891 Hines Paul WS9 1.639 1891 Holliday Bug CIN 11.828 1891 Honan Marty CHN 0.200 1891 Hoy Dummy SL4 16.384 1891 Hughey Jim ML3 0.200 1891 Hurley Jerry CN3 0.492 1891 Hutchison Bill CHN 0.261 1891 Inks Bert BRO 0.200 1891 Irwin Arthur BS2 0.200 1891 Irwin John MULT 0.472 1891 Jennings Hughie LS2 4.013 1891 Johnson Bill BL3 12.253 1891 Johnston Dick CN3 3.338 1891 Johnson Spud CL4 2.052 1891 Joyce Bill BS2 6.953 1891 Keefe George WS9 0.200 1891 Keefe Tim MULT 0.200 1891 Keenan Jim CIN 1.460 1891 Keenan Kid CN3 0.200 1891 Kelley Joe BSN 0.200 1891 Kelly King MULT 5.852 1891 Kiley John BSN 0.200 1891 Killen Frank ML3 0.200 1891 Killeen Henry CL4 0.200 1891 Kilroy Matt CN3 0.200 1891 Kilroy Mike PHI 0.200 1891 King Silver PIT 0.200 1891 Kinslow Tom BRO 0.444 1891 Kittridge Malachi CHN 1.856 1891 Kling Bill PHI 0.200 1891 Knauss Frank CL4 0.200 1891 Knell Phil CL6 0.230 1891 Kuehne Bill MULT 3.663 1891 Lake Fred BSN 0.200 1891 Lally Dan PIT 0.475 1891 Larkin Henry PH4 14.140 1891 LaRoque Sam MULT 0.200 1891 Latham Arlie CIN 14.897 1891 Lehane Mike CL6 4.590 1891 Leiper Jack CL6 0.200 1891 Letcher Tom ML3 0.200 1891 Lohman Pete WS9 0.537 1891 Long Herman BSN 16.759 1891 Long Jim LS2 0.200 1891 Lovett Tom BRO 0.200 1891 Lowe Bobby BSN 7.389 1891 Luby Pat CHN 0.658 1891 Lyons Denny SL4 15.239 1891 Lyston John CL6 0.200 |
1891
Mace Jimmy
WS9 0.200 1891 Mack Connie PIT 2.027 1891 Madden Kid MULT 0.690 1891 Mains Willard MULT 0.353 1891 Marr Lefty MULT 1.863 1891 Matthews Bob PH4 0.200 1891 Maul Al PIT 0.245 1891 Mayer Ed PHI 0.981 1891 McAleer Jimmy CL4 8.738 1891 McCarthy Tommy SL4 12.431 1891 McCauley Al WS9 1.916 1891 McGeachy Jack MULT 2.359 1891 McGill Willie MULT 0.319 1891 McGraw John BL3 0.853 1891 McGuire Deacon WS9 11.914 1891 McKean Ed CL4 13.151 1891 McKeough Dave PH4 0.339 1891 McLaughlin Tom WS9 0.488 1891 McMahon Sadie BL3 0.232 1891 McPhee Bid CIN 9.997 1891 McQuaid Mart SL4 0.200 1891 McQuery Mox WS9 1.279 1891 McSweeney Paul SL4 0.200 1891 McTamany Jim MULT 13.031 1891 Meakim George PH4 0.200 1891 Meekin Jouett LS2 0.394 1891 Merritt Bill CHN 0.200 1891 Miller Bob WS9 0.200 1891 Miller Doggie PIT 8.389 1891 Milligan Jocko PH4 21.264 1891 Morelock Harry PHI 0.200 1891 Mullane Tony CIN 0.225 1891 Mulvey Joe PH4 5.519 1891 Munyan John SL4 0.935 1891 Murphy Larry WS9 4.833 1891 Murphy Morgan BS2 5.679 1891 Murray Miah WS9 0.200 1891 Myers Al PHI 6.650 1891 Nagle Tom CHN 0.200 1891 Nash Billy BSN 12.376 1891 Neale Joe SL4 0.200 1891 Newell John PIT 0.200 1891 Nichols Kid BSN 0.200 1891 Nicol George CHN 0.200 1891 O'Brien Darby BRO 5.436 1891 O'Brien Darby BS2 0.200 1891 O'Brien John BRO 0.389 1891 O'Connor Jack CL6 1.213 1891 O'Connell John BL3 0.200 1891 O'Neill Tip SL4 13.767 1891 O'Rourke Jim NY1 12.931 1891 O'Rourke Tim CL6 0.820 1891 Pettee Pat LS2 0.200 1891 Pettit Bob ML3 0.200 1891 Pfeffer Fred CHN 9.623 1891 Pinkney George BRO 10.262 1891 Plock Walter PHI 0.200 1891 Quarles Bill WS9 0.200 1891 Quinlan Frank BS2 0.200 1891 Quinn Joe BSN 4.407 1891 Radbourn Charley CIN 0.200 1891 Radford Paul BS2 12.663 1891 Ray Irv BL3 4.907 1891 Raymond Harry LS2 0.200 1891 Reeder Nick LS2 0.200 1891 Reilly Charlie PIT 2.865 1891 Reilly John CIN 5.167 1891 Rettger George SL4 0.200 1891 Rhines Billy CIN 0.200 1891 Richardson Danny NY1 7.039 1891 Richardson Hardy BS2 3.088 1891 Ricks John SL4 0.200 1891 Robinson Wilbert BL3 2.656 1891 Robinson Yank MULT 1.931 1891 Rooks George BSN 0.200 1891 Rusie Amos NY1 0.307 1891 Ryan Cyclone BSN 0.200 1891 Ryan Jack LS2 1.307 1891 Ryan Jimmy CHN 12.434 1891 Sanders Ben PH4 0.433 1891 Saylor Phil PHI 0.200 1891 Schellhase Al LS2 0.200 1891 Schriver Pop CHN 2.395 1891 Schultze John PHI 0.200 1891 Schultz John SL4 0.200 1891 Seery Emmett CN3 7.099 1891 Seward Ed CL4 0.200 1891 Shannon Dan WS9 0.200 1891 Sharrott Jack NY1 0.200 1891 Shearon John CL4 0.200 1891 Shindle Billy PHI 3.500 1891 Shinnick Tim LS2 4.665 1891 Shoch George ML3 1.361 1891 Shugart Frank PIT 3.520 1891 Slagle John CN3 0.200 1891 Slattery Mike MULT 0.472 1891 Smalley Will WS9 0.200 1891 Smith Germany CIN 5.590 1891 Smith Phenomenal PHI 0.200 1891 Smith Pop WS9 0.205 1891 Sneed John CL6 5.017 1891 Snyder Pop WS9 0.200 1891 Spurney Ed PIT 0.200 1891 Staley Harry MULT 0.200 1891 Stein Ed CHN 0.200 1891 Stephens Clarence CIN 0.200 1891 Stivetts Jack SL4 2.308 1891 Stovey Harry BSN 18.494 1891 Stratton Scott MULT 0.219 1891 Stricker Cub BS2 6.851 1891 Sullivan Jim MULT 0.200 1891 Sullivan Marty MULT 0.223 1891 Sullivan Mike MULT 0.200 1891 Sutcliffe Sy WS9 3.196 1891 Taylor Harry LS2 4.294 1891 Taylor Jack NY1 0.200 1891 Tebeau Patsy CL4 1.583 1891 Terry Adonis BRO 0.321 1891 Thompson Sam PHI 15.021 1891 Thornton John PHI 0.200 1891 Tiernan Mike NY1 21.436 1891 Townsend George BL3 0.416 1891 Tucker Tommy BSN 7.474 1891 Twitchell Larry CL6 1.599 1891 Van Haltren George BL3 21.128 1891 Vaughn Farmer MULT 1.755 1891 Viau Lee CL4 0.200 1891 Vickery Tom CHN 0.200 1891 Virtue Jake CL4 8.248 1891 Visner Joe MULT 0.500 1891 Walsh Joe BL3 0.200 1891 Ward John BRO 4.901 1891 Ward Piggy PIT 0.200 1891 Weaver Farmer LS2 9.341 1891 Welch Curt BL3 14.495 1891 Welch Mickey NY1 0.200 1891 Wentz Jack LS2 0.200 1891 Werden Perry BL3 14.884 1891 Weyhing Gus PH4 0.200 1891 Wheelock Bobby CL6 7.717 1891 Whistler Lew NY1 1.650 1891 Whitney Art MULT 2.184 1891 Whitney Art SL4 0.200 1891 Widner Wild Bill CN3 0.200 1891 Wilmot Walt CHN 10.792 1891 Wise Sam BL3 3.839 1891 Wolf Jimmy LS2 8.421 1891 Wood George PH4 15.229 1891 Young Cy CL4 0.200 1891 Zies Bill SL4 0.200 1891 Zimmer Chief CL4 7.061 |
Note: HR/RBI/OBP/SLG/FV (Field Value) for Position Players, W/SV/IP/ERA for Pitchers. Note: Maximum PEVA of 32.000 for Salary Purposes shown above. Using Final Park Factors.
What is PEVA?
PEVA is the acronym for Stat Geek Baseball's New Player Rating value. This grade is given to each player and pitcher each season, rating their performance on a peer to peer review. Six components for pitchers and batters are melded together into the PEVA Rating, which ranges each year from 0.200 to 64.000. For more information on PEVA and the other new Stat Geek Baseball Stats, see our Definitions page. PEVA ratings are available for every pitcher and hitter in baseball history.
PEVA Scale
64.000 - Maximum
32.000 - Cy Young/MVP Candidate
20.000 - All League
15.000 - All-Star Level
10.000 - Very Good
3.500 - Average
0.200 - Minimum
Notes: Photo/Image Credits: Hugh Duffy, Dan Brouthers, Cap Anson, 1800s Baseball Scene, Shibe Park; Library of Congress
Baseball Evaluation, Stat Geek Baseball, and all materials on this site are the 2015 Copyright and intellectual property of JDP ECON and their licensors. All worldwide rights reserved. The Baseball Evaluation system was developed independently of Major League Baseball and the Major League Baseball Players Association and is not endorsed by or associated in any way with either organization.
Note: All Baseball Evaluation Stats and Stat Geek Baseball Stats were developed by JDP Econ & are the proprietary property of JDP ECON. All rights reserved. If Baseball Evaluation stats are used in articles, etc., please credit statgeekbaseball.com or baseballevaluation.com.
For more on the Best Teams Ever, including the Top 50 batting, pitching, and total teams, plus more, check out Stat Geek Baseball, the Best Ever Book below.
More Baseball
Cap Anson
Hugh Duffy
Fields of Gold, Baseball's Best Glove tracks the best fielders in baseball history, including the best of every team. And if you want even more detail and rankings about the Best Ever batters and pitchers, check out Stat Geek Baseball, the Best Ever Book. It's the book that started it all.
More Stat Geek Baseball
Best Ever Seasons by Team
Best Teams Ever
Hall of Fame Ranks
Best Pitching Seasons
Best Batting Seasons