• Stat Geek Baseball

Best Baseball Players Ever

Image above: Tag play at the base. Image courtesy Library of Congress.

Schibe Park

Best Baseball Players of All-Time

1871-2015 (Regular Season).

Both Batting and Pitching.



Rk Name Last HOF PEVA
Bat
PEVA
Pitch
PEVA
Total
Yrs. PEVA
PerYr
Career
Hits
HR RBI Ave. W L SV ERA
41 Pedro Martinez HOFP 0 328.493 328.493 18 18.250 43 0 18 0.099 219 100 3 2.93
42 Dave Winfield HOFP 327.768 0 327.768 22 14.899 3110 465 1833 0.283
43 Tom Glavine HOFP 0.229 325.047 325.276 22 14.785 246 1 90 0.186 305 203 0 3.54
44 Eddie Murray HOFP 324.361 0 324.361 21 15.446 3255
504 1917 0.287
45 Cal Ripken HOFP 320.188 0 320.188 21 15.247 3184
431 1695 0.276
46 Kid Nichols HOFP 1.186 315.802 316.988 15 21.133 472 16 278 0.226 361 208 17 2.95
47 Robin Roberts HOFP 1.699 307.347 309.046 19 16.266 255 5 103 0.167 286 245 25 3.41
48 Miguel Cabrera 307.490 0 307.490 13 23.653 2331 408 1445 0.321
49 Roy Halladay NYE 0 304.746 304.746 16 19.047 34 0 12 0.124 203 105 1 3.38
50 Carl Hubbell HOFP 0.088 301.955 302.043 16 18.878 246 4 101 0.191 253 154 33 2.98
51 George Brett HOFP 301.897 0 301.897 21 14.376 3154 317 1595 0.305
52 John Smoltz HOFP 0.353 301.456 301.809 21 14.372 151 5 61 0.159 213 155 154 3.33
53 Reggie Jackson HOFP 301.318 0 301.318 21 14.348 2584 563 1702 0.262
54 Joe DiMaggio HOFP 297.630 0 297.630 13 22.895 2214 361 1537 0.325
55 Al Kaline HOFP 297.259 0 297.259 22 13.512 3007 399 1583 0.297
56 Sam Crawford HOFP 295.985 0 295.985 19 15.578 2961 97 1525 0.309
57 Jeff Bagwell HOFP 293.606 0 293.606 15 19.574 2314 449 1529 0.297
58 Christy Mathewson HOFP 2.557 290.943 293.500 17 17.265 362 7 165 0.215 373 188 28 2.13
59 Wade Boggs HOFP 293.035 0 293.035 18 16.280 3010 118 1014 0.328 0 0 0 3.86
60 Robin Yount HOFP 291.976 0 291.976 20 14.599 3142 251 1406 0.285


Sponsor this page for $75 per year or all Best Players Ever Total pages for $200. Your banner or text ad can fill the space above. Click here to Sponsor the page and see how to reserve your ad.


Babe Ruth, like no other player in history, combined the ability to hit and pitch at a maximum level. In his early career with the Boston Red Sox, Ruth was a premier pitcher, winning 23 games in 1916 at the age of 21. His Earned Run Average that year was 1.75 over 323.7 innings pitched. But Ruth was not a one year wonder, winning 24 games the next year with a 2.01 ERA. Even though it may seem so today, the era that Ruth pitched in really was not a hybrid era. That time had predominantly passed. In pre-1900 baseball leagues, it was commonplace for a player to both pitch and play a position on those days when he didn't take the mound. See the statistics for someone like Al Spalding for the example of a hybrid pitcher and batter who did both at Hall of Fame levels, but by the time of Ruth and his exploits, it was rare.

Want more detail, check out the Stat Geek Baseball, the Best Ever Book excerpts by clicking any of the Top Five players in baseball history.

Notes: Photo Credits: Babe Ruth, Eddie Collins, Frank Baker, Ty Cobb, Christy Mathewson, Grover Cleveland Alexander, and Tris Speaker (Library of Congress).

Note: Age = Player age at the End of the Calendar Year. PEVA-B = PEVA Batting Player Rating. Note: HOF (Hall of Fame), HOFP - Hall of Fame Player. NYE - Not Yet Eligible. NO - Eligible, Not Elected.

PEVA-P for player with higher batting total only includes PEVA above minimum value for pitching, i.e. the additional value for the pitcher per season. PEVA-B for players with higher pitching total only includes PEVA above minimum value for batting, i.e. the additional value for the batter per season.

Baseball Evaluation, Stat Geek Baseball, and all materials on this site are the 2015 Copyright and intellectual property of JDP ECON and their licensors. All worldwide rights reserved. The Baseball Evaluation system was developed independently of Major League Baseball and the Major League Baseball Players Association and is not endorsed by or associated in any way with either organization.

Note: All Baseball Evaluation Stats and Stat Geek Baseball Stats were developed by JDP Econ & are the proprietary property of JDP ECON. All rights reserved. If Baseball Evaluation stats are used in articles, etc., please credit statgeekbaseball.com or baseballevaluation.com.

  • What is PEVA?

    PEVA is the acronym for Stat Geek Baseball's New Player Rating value. This grade is given to each player and pitcher each season, rating their performance on a peer to peer review. Six components for pitchers and batters are melded together into the PEVA Rating, which ranges each year from 0.200 to 64.000. For more information on PEVA and the other new Stat Geek Baseball Stats, see our Definitions page. PEVA ratings are available for every pitcher and hitter in baseball history.

    PEVA Scale

    64.000 - Maximum
    32.000 - Cy Young/MVP Candidate
    20.000 - All League
    15.000 - All-Star Level
    10.000 - Very Good
    3.500 - Average
    0.200 - Minimum

More Baseball